People keep moving like an enterprise

Enterprises Are Like People

Enterprises are like people – that’s why they are so hard to define and describe

We have recently produced a series of blog posts addressing the question of why Enterprise Architecture (EA) has to be so complicated. The main reason for this is of course that individual enterprises are themselves inherently complex. Because of this unavoidable fact, ‘proper’ EA needs to model this reality. A major contributor to this complexity is the very nature of the modern enterprise which is typically formed from a group of interlocking business services, many of which are outside the direct control of the central organising body. We have also seen that commercial firms competing in the same industry sector can have significant differences in their structures, depending on such factors as their approaches to the market, their local regulatory and fiscal constraints, and their historical legacies. Government agencies across the world often face similar challenges, but history and politics influence the way they tackle them – and therefore how they are organised.

The Challenges

The challenges of modelling this complexity were recognised many years ago by John Zachman, a world-renowned authority in the EA field who created a comprehensive framework to help with the task. One of Zachman’s key insights was to recognise that at times of major organisational change ‘enterprise frustration’ tended to kick in, as people realised that their previous attempts to model the organisation were no longer valid. Recognising the detailed intricacy of the task, he argued for the need for ‘engineering descriptions’ of the architectural components of an enterprise to provide a sound basis for launching change initiatives. He correctly pointed out that “there is no way to change Boeing 747s quickly (or safely) without starting with the product description”.

As Zachman clearly recognised, managing the changes to the design of an aeroplane relies on far more than an accurate list of parts. Equally important from a performance and safety perspective are the ways in which these components fit together, how their functions are monitored and controlled by the aircraft’s avionics, and the training requirements of the flight deck crew members. This is certainly analogous to the interdependence of the business capabilities and processes, the IT applications, the data stores and the technologies that underpin an enterprise.

The Problem

The problem with such mechanistic views of the enterprise, however, is that they underplay the human factors. Cultural norms, social dynamics and personal agendas also guide the shape and direction of an organisation, and these hidden factors usually have a critical influence on its day-to-day operations. It is these influences that serve to make individual organisations unique, even where they share common structural patterns with other enterprises in the same line of business.

How is an Enterprise like the body?

Rather than comparing the architecture of an enterprise with the structure of an aircraft, we prefer the analogy of the human anatomy. At its most basic level, having a complete list of all the bones of the human skeleton is of no practical use unless you know exactly how they are linked together and the functions of the groups to which they belong. Furthermore, if you are a physiotherapist treating a patient, you need to know how the various groups of bones are moved by the muscles to which they are attached and which nerves control those muscles. But two identical patients with the same conditions may respond differently to treatment depending on their individual motivation, and this is where the human factors come into play.

It is probably unrealistic to expect an enterprise architect to comprehensively model even the mechanistic elements of any complex organisation’s current and future operating model in fine detail. But the key lesson here is to appreciate the importance of the human factors both as constraints and as potential enablers of progress. This is why we have previously argued that enterprise architects should be prepared to engage with corporate politics in a positive way.

Contact Us