avoid business disasters with ai

Can AI shield you from business disasters?

How smart use of AI with a powerful EA Repository can avoid Business Disasters

In a recent blog we discussed how the uncontrolled application of artificial intelligence can adversely impact the outcomes of major business transformation programmes. We argued that successful use of AI in such cases requires smart people who understand the organisation, who are supported by effective governance mechanisms, and who have access to reliable and relevant knowledge of the business operating model. This knowledge of the operating model is best captured in an enterprise architecture repository that not only contains the various organisational elements, but also the critical real-world connections and dependencies between those elements. We call this the ‘Connected Organisation’.

This combination of smart people, effective governance measures and organisational knowledge is not only relevant for AI-enabled business transformation programmes; it can also be coupled with AI to give early warning of pitfalls and potential disasters in the realm of what people may regard as ‘business as usual’. The Boiling Frog Syndrome may be a hackneyed (and scientifically incorrect) metaphor, but it aptly describes the tendency of people in organisations to tolerate and ignore gradual, accumulating, negative changes until matters reach crisis point.

So how can AI help to address this particular problem? One of the most powerful and positive features of AI is its ability to analyse data and recognise unusual patterns much faster and more accurately than people. This distinctive capability of AI is already having huge impacts in the field of medical diagnosis, and we believe that AI could make similarly dramatic contributions in business when applied to a truly connected organisation. The following case study illustrates the potential of this.

Example of a Disconnected Organisation – the British Post Office Scandal

The British Post Office Scandal resulted from the Post Office management’s pursuit between 1999 and 2015 of thousands of innocent subpostmasters for financial shortfalls caused by faults in Horizon, a branch accounting system developed by Fujitsu. Hundreds of subpostmasters were wrongly convicted of theft or fraud based on incorrect data, whilst others, who were prosecuted but not convicted, were forced to cover the shortfalls with their own money or were dismissed without pay. The stress of criminal convictions, imprisonments, loss of livelihoods, debts and bankruptcies led to family breakdowns, mental and physical illness, individuals being harried as thieves in their own communities, and several suicides.

At the heart of this appalling scandal were major disconnects between different parts of one of the Post Office’s core business capabilities which happened to span two separate companies. The top management claimed from the outset that Fujitsu’s Horizon accounting system was totally reliable, and they refused to believe their own subpostmasters when they reported discrepancies.

The Post Office management also asserted throughout that the branch accounts could not be accessed remotely by any other party. Yet Fujitsu staff were able to adjust the accounts, which they sometimes did in misguided attempts to help the subpostmasters. As evidence of the miscarriages of justice built up over the years, the Post Office bosses held on doggedly to their original position until this became untenable and the Government stepped in. Even today, compensation claims are still being settled.

What We can Learn From This Business Disaster

This case study provides an extreme example of what can happen when knowledge of the organisation is fragmented. With deep and reliable knowledge of the total business operating model, particularly if supported by appropriate AI facilities, the emerging abnormal pattern of financial discrepancies would surely have been spotted at an early stage. For example, were the Post Office’s methods of vetting potential subpostmasters really so flawed that the organisation had been hiring large numbers of people with criminal intent over such a long period?

Although Fujitsu’s practice of adjusting the branch accounts was ‘unofficial’, this case also highlights the dangers of outsourcing a critical business activity to an external firm without full knowledge of the processes involved and without adequate means of monitoring and controlling them. Rigorous governance measures of the kind mentioned above might have raised questions earlier.

When the full extent of the Post Office scandal was clearly exposed, the CEO claimed that she had been misadvised by her legal and IT experts. Perhaps so. But with reliable knowledge of the business operating model, shared across the wider organisation and interpreted with the help of powerful AI facilities, advice to top management in a similar situation today should be clear, well-founded and communicated early. Although there is of course no guarantee that the recipients of such advice would act appropriately, there would certainly be no excuse for not doing so.

 

Author: Alex Mayall – LinkedIn

Contact Us